Secretary Geithner’s Plan has finally been unveiled and the hubbub begins. As could be predicted, there are more detractors of the plan than MSNBC hosts in support of it. Most say it wont fly because we’re relying on the same people who got us in to this mess to get us out. Others say the country simply cant endure this costly solution. Perhaps all this is true. Then what feasible alternatives are out there?
The Noble winner Paul Krugman suggest that we nationalize the largest and worst performing banks and hold on to their toxic assets—the phrase seems to have gathered some heat so I’ll use it—until they’re worth something again. He also asserts that the Obama administration along with Congress is so intrinsically connected to Wall Street that they are unable to envision a solution that doesn’t serve it. To his credit (he is a Noble Laureate by the way), he produces some pretty convincing evidence to support his claims. Sweden, for example, went the route of nationalization and turned a bad situation into good in less than five years. As regards the Wall Street connection, that’s a pretty tough one to argue. Certainly, people advancing agenda in the government’s financial sector would be expected to have some practical hands-on knowledge of the machinations of Wall Street.
But if we are to pursue Krugman’s argument to its logical conclusion, an inherently cyclical structure begins to emerge. If we follow Sweden’s lead and nationalize the banks then aren’t we throwing our lot in with the same scoundrels that he criticizes as being in the pocket of Wall Street? Wouldn’t we essentially be relying on these administrative surrogates and Congressional lackeys to run the banks? As inept as the Executive Branch and Congress have been in the past, I don’t think most Americans would feel absolutely comfortable handing the keys over to these guys and gals.
Not to single Krugman out as the only detractor, but he is the only one with any kind of alternative vision. The only other emanated from the esteemed free-marketist Newt Gingrich, who simply advised bankruptcy as a solution.
Admittedly, I have not read of any serious economist willing to bet a dime on the Gaithner Plan. Not being an economist myself, I hesitate to put too much stock in my own ruminations. However, considering the gravity of this current economical crisis, it would seem that some think tank or group of intellectuals could merge their collective eggheads and come up with something to seriously challenge the Geithner solution. As I recall, there was no shortage of commentary coming from their quarter during the election.
Tuesday, March 24, 2009
Sunday, March 22, 2009
Bonus Envy
Bonuses…bonuses…bonuses…we’re talking bonuses here, right? Are you kiddin me?
With America suffering a double digit unemployment rate and banks falling like bowling pins, American’s lucky enough to still be receiving a piece of the pie need to evaluate just how much of that shrinking pie they are getting. The disparity between the haves and have-nots is equal, if not greater, than it has been since the Gilded Age. Just in case you need reminding, that was the age of the great robber barons: Getty, Rockefeller, Vanderbilt, and the likes ruled with impunity and there was little, if any, government regulation to temper their reign. The majority of working Americans lived what would now be considered below the poverty level with little job security and even less benefits.
As we know from history, this period of unadulterated capitalist power and greed culminated in a total collapse of the economic system. Sound familiar? Not until FDR propped up the flaccid economy with an aggressive stimulus package and a World War did Americans begin to enjoy the semblance of a middle-class. The country flourished economically through this government restructuring.
As a result of the New Deal, and the government’s active involvement in fair employment practices, the quality of living for a large number of Americans had greatly improved. By the 50’s, the largest employer in the world was General Motors. Its employees enjoyed a comfortable salary (about 40K by today’s standards) and a nice benefits package including medical insurance.
The remnants of the New Deal hung around for the next thirty odd years despite Conservative’s demonization of the plan. However, by the turn of the century, comfortable Americans had finally been convinced that it wasn’t in their best interest to continue being their brother’s keeper. Phrases like welfare mom’s and capital gains taxes successfully infiltrated the national dialogue. Unions became a naughty reminder of unbridled corruption.
Now here we are, 2009. Wal-Mart is the largest employer in the world. Their average wage hovers somewhere around 8 bucks hour. You ask about benefits. Maybe its best you don’t. And by most economists’ projections, the middle-class has seen a negative growth in their household incomes in the last ten years. Meanwhile CEO’s are pulling in massive salaries that would have been an embarrassment to a corporation twenty years ago.
So perhaps its time for us to not spend as much time worrying about something as incidental as a bonus and instead, direct our attention at what type of system would allow these kinds of indiscretions to be a matter of course. I can only hope that the new Geithner Plan doesn’t attempt to solve this problem by using the same methods that caused it.
With America suffering a double digit unemployment rate and banks falling like bowling pins, American’s lucky enough to still be receiving a piece of the pie need to evaluate just how much of that shrinking pie they are getting. The disparity between the haves and have-nots is equal, if not greater, than it has been since the Gilded Age. Just in case you need reminding, that was the age of the great robber barons: Getty, Rockefeller, Vanderbilt, and the likes ruled with impunity and there was little, if any, government regulation to temper their reign. The majority of working Americans lived what would now be considered below the poverty level with little job security and even less benefits.
As we know from history, this period of unadulterated capitalist power and greed culminated in a total collapse of the economic system. Sound familiar? Not until FDR propped up the flaccid economy with an aggressive stimulus package and a World War did Americans begin to enjoy the semblance of a middle-class. The country flourished economically through this government restructuring.
As a result of the New Deal, and the government’s active involvement in fair employment practices, the quality of living for a large number of Americans had greatly improved. By the 50’s, the largest employer in the world was General Motors. Its employees enjoyed a comfortable salary (about 40K by today’s standards) and a nice benefits package including medical insurance.
The remnants of the New Deal hung around for the next thirty odd years despite Conservative’s demonization of the plan. However, by the turn of the century, comfortable Americans had finally been convinced that it wasn’t in their best interest to continue being their brother’s keeper. Phrases like welfare mom’s and capital gains taxes successfully infiltrated the national dialogue. Unions became a naughty reminder of unbridled corruption.
Now here we are, 2009. Wal-Mart is the largest employer in the world. Their average wage hovers somewhere around 8 bucks hour. You ask about benefits. Maybe its best you don’t. And by most economists’ projections, the middle-class has seen a negative growth in their household incomes in the last ten years. Meanwhile CEO’s are pulling in massive salaries that would have been an embarrassment to a corporation twenty years ago.
So perhaps its time for us to not spend as much time worrying about something as incidental as a bonus and instead, direct our attention at what type of system would allow these kinds of indiscretions to be a matter of course. I can only hope that the new Geithner Plan doesn’t attempt to solve this problem by using the same methods that caused it.
Friday, March 13, 2009
The Stockade
Just finished watching The Daily Show and was struck by how blunt John Stewart was with the CNBC analyst and host Jim Cramer. Having reflected on the interview for a while, I realized that if there ever was an example of how America wrestles with the dilemma of balancing idealism with realism this is it.
The high-minded idealism of a market left free and unfettered by stringent government regulations is what every sensible American believed was necessary for a healthy functional economy. And with more and more people having a vested interest in the stock market through 401k retirement plans, this seemed—so far—to be an obvious maxim. As long as the returns remained consistent, not many were willing to question, or for that matter, pursue the money trail. And then the sky fell.
All of the sudden the idealistic vision of free markets didn’t appear so bright after all. The people demanded answers; answers to a question they never really understood in the first place. Aside from signing a signature on a stack of papers, few people did more to understand what was happening with that hundred bucks being deducted from their check every couple of weeks. Meanwhile, realism appeared in the form of a group of dodgy brokers juggling your funds through loops and holes that the SEC didn’t even fully comprehend.
So for this ignorance, there was a price to pay. Only, no one realized how dire the cost would be. Its time to appreciate that we all are complicit in this situation. Only then will we be able to heal as a country and reconcile our commitment to idealism and temper it with a reasonable dose realism.
The high-minded idealism of a market left free and unfettered by stringent government regulations is what every sensible American believed was necessary for a healthy functional economy. And with more and more people having a vested interest in the stock market through 401k retirement plans, this seemed—so far—to be an obvious maxim. As long as the returns remained consistent, not many were willing to question, or for that matter, pursue the money trail. And then the sky fell.
All of the sudden the idealistic vision of free markets didn’t appear so bright after all. The people demanded answers; answers to a question they never really understood in the first place. Aside from signing a signature on a stack of papers, few people did more to understand what was happening with that hundred bucks being deducted from their check every couple of weeks. Meanwhile, realism appeared in the form of a group of dodgy brokers juggling your funds through loops and holes that the SEC didn’t even fully comprehend.
So for this ignorance, there was a price to pay. Only, no one realized how dire the cost would be. Its time to appreciate that we all are complicit in this situation. Only then will we be able to heal as a country and reconcile our commitment to idealism and temper it with a reasonable dose realism.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
