Secretary Geithner’s Plan has finally been unveiled and the hubbub begins. As could be predicted, there are more detractors of the plan than MSNBC hosts in support of it. Most say it wont fly because we’re relying on the same people who got us in to this mess to get us out. Others say the country simply cant endure this costly solution. Perhaps all this is true. Then what feasible alternatives are out there?
The Noble winner Paul Krugman suggest that we nationalize the largest and worst performing banks and hold on to their toxic assets—the phrase seems to have gathered some heat so I’ll use it—until they’re worth something again. He also asserts that the Obama administration along with Congress is so intrinsically connected to Wall Street that they are unable to envision a solution that doesn’t serve it. To his credit (he is a Noble Laureate by the way), he produces some pretty convincing evidence to support his claims. Sweden, for example, went the route of nationalization and turned a bad situation into good in less than five years. As regards the Wall Street connection, that’s a pretty tough one to argue. Certainly, people advancing agenda in the government’s financial sector would be expected to have some practical hands-on knowledge of the machinations of Wall Street.
But if we are to pursue Krugman’s argument to its logical conclusion, an inherently cyclical structure begins to emerge. If we follow Sweden’s lead and nationalize the banks then aren’t we throwing our lot in with the same scoundrels that he criticizes as being in the pocket of Wall Street? Wouldn’t we essentially be relying on these administrative surrogates and Congressional lackeys to run the banks? As inept as the Executive Branch and Congress have been in the past, I don’t think most Americans would feel absolutely comfortable handing the keys over to these guys and gals.
Not to single Krugman out as the only detractor, but he is the only one with any kind of alternative vision. The only other emanated from the esteemed free-marketist Newt Gingrich, who simply advised bankruptcy as a solution.
Admittedly, I have not read of any serious economist willing to bet a dime on the Gaithner Plan. Not being an economist myself, I hesitate to put too much stock in my own ruminations. However, considering the gravity of this current economical crisis, it would seem that some think tank or group of intellectuals could merge their collective eggheads and come up with something to seriously challenge the Geithner solution. As I recall, there was no shortage of commentary coming from their quarter during the election.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteI concur whole heartedly. Especially about the eggheads.
ReplyDeleteAs stated by you very well, there are no others coming forth with a plan except the President's man and P. Krugman who resist any leadership role with service to the country but has plenty of criticism, if and only if his theories are not being used. But once again as stated by you he is a noble laureate and he may know a thing or two about economics but as stated its all theories and only time will tell which ones or combinations will work to pull us out of this mess. This may sound old and tired in this fast paced age but time is needed to correct the years of economic devastation that wrecked this country
ReplyDelete